Islamophobia, often seen as a post-9/11 phenomenon, is much older than recent events suggest. While the tragic attacks of September 11, 2001, undoubtedly intensified anti-Muslim sentiments worldwide, reducing Islamophobia to this event oversimplifies its historical roots. A closer examination reveals that Islamophobia has a much longer history, rooted in European colonialism, the Crusades, and the centuries-old cultural and religious conflicts between Europe and the Muslim world.
This deeper history of Islamophobia helps to explain why Muslims have long been viewed with suspicion, fear, and hostility in Europe. The demonisation of Muslims did not start with the rise of Islamist terrorism but has been woven into the fabric of European history for centuries, sustained through various forms of political, military, and cultural confrontation. Understanding these origins is crucial to grappling with the complex reality of Islamophobia today.
The Role of Colonialism in Shaping the Image of Muslim Inferiority
Colonialism played a pivotal role in shaping European attitudes toward Muslims. As European powers expanded their empires in the 19th and early 20th centuries, they subjugated large portions of the Muslim world, particularly in North Africa, the Middle East, and South Asia. In doing so, they constructed an image of Muslims as culturally and intellectually inferior. This colonial mindset, driven by a belief in European superiority, portrayed Muslims as backward, uneducated, and incapable of progress.
This portrayal was deeply rooted in racial and cultural prejudices, with European colonisers viewing Islam and Muslim societies through an Orientalist lens—a concept coined by Edward Said. Orientalism framed the “East” (or the Muslim world) as exotic, irrational, and uncivilised in contrast to the “West”, which was seen as rational, modern, and enlightened. Such views justified the colonial domination of Muslim territories and the exploitation of their resources. In this context, Islamophobia became intertwined with the colonial project, manifesting as both racial and cultural prejudice against Muslims.
Scholars like Franz Fanon and Gayatri Spivak have further explored the colonial roots of racism and cultural discrimination. Fanon, in particular, highlighted how colonisers dehumanised the native populations, including Muslims, portraying them as “primitive others” in need of European enlightenment. Spivak’s concept of the “subaltern” also underscores the voicelessness and marginalisation of colonised peoples, particularly Muslim women, in colonial narratives.
How the Crusades Sparked European-Muslim Tensions
Even before colonialism, Islamophobia had deep roots in the religious wars between Christians and Muslims during the medieval period. The Crusades, which began in the 11th century, were a series of religious wars initiated by European Christians to reclaim Jerusalem from Muslim control. These conflicts were not only about territorial control but also about religious and cultural dominance.
The rhetoric surrounding the Crusades portrayed Muslims as the enemy of Christianity and the West. Christian leaders demonised Muslims, describing them as pagans and infidels. Pope Urban II, who launched the First Crusade in 1095, referred to Muslims as a “race utterly alienated from God” and called for their elimination to liberate the Holy Land. This language created a clear division between “us” (Christian Europe) and “them” (Muslim enemies), reinforcing the idea that Muslims were not only religious adversaries but also culturally and morally inferior.
The Crusades left a lasting legacy of hostility and suspicion toward Muslims, which continued to shape European attitudes long after the military conflicts ended. The idea of Muslims as a dangerous and barbaric “other” persisted in European cultural consciousness, influencing how Muslims were perceived in the centuries that followed.
Islamophobia After 9/11: A Modern-Day Reality
The attacks on September 11, 2001, undoubtedly marked a significant moment in the history of Islamophobia, particularly in the West. The rise of terrorism, particularly Al-Qaeda and later ISIS, fueled a global wave of anti-Muslim sentiments. However, framing Islamophobia solely as a post-9/11 phenomenon ignores the longer historical context that has shaped anti-Muslim attitudes in Europe.
9/11 served as a catalyst for the resurgence of Islamophobia, but it was not the root cause. Instead, it reignited pre-existing prejudices that had been dormant in European societies. These prejudices, deeply ingrained through centuries of religious and colonial conflicts, were reawakened by the fear of terrorism. Muslims, who had already been viewed with suspicion, were now seen as potential terrorists, regardless of their individual identities or beliefs.
This resurgence of Islamophobia after 9/11 was also shaped by broader geopolitical factors, including the “War on Terror” and the refugee crisis. In the wake of these events, Muslims were increasingly portrayed as a threat to Western security and values. Political leaders and media outlets perpetuated the idea that Muslim immigrants posed a danger to European societies, fueling fears of an “Islamisation” of the West.
Muslim ‘Othering’: Cultural and Religious Perspectives
One of the key aspects of Islamophobia, both historically and in the present, is the “othering” of Muslims. This process of “othering” involves framing Muslims as fundamentally different from, and inferior to, European Christians. It is not only a fear of Islam as a religion but also a rejection of Muslims as people, based on the perception that they are culturally incompatible with Western values.
This cultural racism is rooted in the colonial and medieval histories of Europe, where Muslims were depicted as enemies of civilisation and progress. Today, this manifests in the widespread belief that Islam is inherently opposed to modernity and human rights. Conspiracy theories about the “Islamisation” of Europe and the erosion of Western values by Muslim immigrants reflect this ongoing process of cultural othering.
Conclusion: The Historical Roots of Islamophobia
While the events of 9/11 brought Islamophobia to the forefront of global consciousness, they are not the starting point of this phenomenon. Islamophobia is deeply rooted in European history, with its origins stretching back to the Crusades and the colonial period. The portrayal of Muslims as a cultural and religious “other” has long been a part of European attitudes toward Islam, sustained by centuries of conflict, colonisation, and cultural domination.
Understanding Islamophobia as a historical phenomenon, rather than a recent development, allows us to see the continuity of anti-Muslim prejudice over time. It also challenges the narrative that Islamophobia is solely a reaction to terrorism. Instead, it is a complex and dynamic process, shaped by cultural, religious, and political factors that have evolved over centuries. Addressing Islamophobia today requires acknowledging these deeper historical roots and confronting the ongoing legacy of colonialism and religious conflict in shaping attitudes toward Muslims.
In this way, the struggle against Islamophobia is not only about combating present-day prejudice but also about reckoning with the long history of European hostility toward Muslims and Islam.
Reference
